What’s Driving U.S. Stock Market Returns?


What’s Driving U.S. Stock Market Returns?
In many ways, U.S. stock market returns in 2023 have defied expectations. Strong U.S. economic activity, a robust labor market, and consumer spending have helped spur investor optimism. Year-to-date, the S&P 500 is up roughly 12%.
Given this unexpected strength, the above graphic, sponsored by New York Life Investments, explores key factors fueling stock market returns in 2023.
Market Breadth
Generally speaking, the concept of market breadth shows how many stocks are participating in the rise or fall of an index.
Wider Breadth: More stocks are rising, often indicating lower risk as gains are widespread.
Narrower Breadth: Fewer stocks are rising, potentially presenting higher risk as gains have a steep impact on the index.
Earlier in 2023, just seven stocks drove virtually all of the S&P 500’s returns. By July, the top 10 companies made up 34% of its gains. Here’s how S&P 500 market breadth compares to historical trends:
Year | Percent of Stocks Outperforming the S&P 500 Index |
---|---|
2023* | 25% |
2022 | 57% |
2021 | 48% |
2020 | 33% |
2019 | 46% |
2018 | 45% |
2017 | 43% |
2016 | 51% |
2015 | 47% |
2014 | 52% |
2013 | 52% |
2012 | 47% |
2011 | 48% |
2010 | 58% |
2009 | 59% |
2008 | 49% |
2007 | 45% |
2006 | 49% |
2005 | 51% |
2004 | 57% |
2003 | 54% |
2002 | 61% |
2001 | 67% |
2000 | 63% |
1999 | 31% |
1998 | 29% |
1997 | 42% |
1996 | 42% |
1995 | 40% |
Source: Bloomberg Finance LP, 06/20/2023. *Data as of June 12, 2023.
While market breadth has been very narrow so far this year, the good news is that it has improved with gains spreading across a growing number of sectors.
Top S&P 500 Sectors
In 2023, the following sectors are driving market returns. Number have been rounded:
S&P 500 Sector | YTD Return | 5-Year Annualized Return |
---|---|---|
Communication Services | +44% | +8% |
Information Technology | +43% | +19% |
Consumer Discretionary | +33% | +8% |
Industrials | +10% | +7% |
S&P 500 Index | +18% | +9% |
Source: S&P Global, 08/31/2023.
Big tech stocks have powered the market’s rise, supported by the AI frenzy. Additionally, strong consumer spending has helped lift the Consumer Discretionary sector.
Overall, we can see the top three performing sectors are cyclical, meaning they rise and fall with the business cycle.
Corporate Earnings
Even with many companies beating earnings expectations, year-over-year S&P 500 profits declined 5.2% in Q2 2023, its worst performance since 2020.
Below, we show how earnings growth breaks down by sector. Numbers have been rounded.
S&P 500 Sector | Year-over-Year Earnings Growth Q2 2023 |
---|---|
Consumer Discretionary | +52% |
Communication Services | +19% |
Industrials | +12% |
Real Estate | +10% |
Financials | +6% |
Consumer Staples | +6% |
Utilities | +5% |
Information Technology | +1% |
Health Care | -28% |
Materials | -29% |
Energy | -51% |
S&P 500 Index | -5% |
Source: FactSet, 08/04/2023.
As of Q2 2023, over half of S&P 500 companies reported positive year-over-year earnings growth. Furthermore, corporate net profit margins remain strong at 11.5%, despite falling from record highs in 2021.
While corporate profitability is slowing, better-than-expected earnings are supporting stock market performance.
Stock Market Returns: A Balanced View
Today, improving market breadth and sturdy corporate earnings across key sectors are supporting the market’s strength.
These factors, along with a solid macroeconomic backdrop, are leading to a brighter economic outlook in the coming year. As a result, investors see a higher likelihood of the economy achieving a soft landing.
In an ever-changing environment, it highlights the importance of working with a financial professional who can provide their clients with actionable and balanced strategies and help them stay on track as they navigate today’s market.

Explore more investment insights with New York Life Investments.

-
Economy1 month ago
Charting U.S. Trade Relationships
Maintaining a balanced perspective on trade is crucial. Which countries does the U.S. have the largest trade deficits and surpluses with?
-
Markets3 months ago
Trading Under Trump: Lessons from 2017-2021
With the second term of Trump underway, all eyes are on the markets to see how they react. Which sectors and regions that thrived last time?
-
Markets6 months ago
2024 in Review: Stock, Bond, and Real Estate Performance
How did equities, fixed income, and real estate (and their underlying sectors) perform in the U.S. throughout 2024?
-
Money8 months ago
Investing in an Era of an Aging Population
The U.S. population is aging. By 2070, the number of people over 65 will outnumber children. How can investors prepare?
-
Politics10 months ago
Does it Matter to the Market Who Wins the White House?
After the president takes office, how have the market and the economy performed under Democrats vs Republicans?
-
Markets11 months ago
Magnificent 7 Mania: Why Diversification Still Matters
The Magnificent Seven stocks all outperformed the S&P 500 in 2023. However, it’s crucial to remember that diversifying a portfolio at both the company level and…
-
Markets1 year ago
What History Reveals About Interest Rate Cuts
How have previous cycles of interest rate cuts in the U.S. impacted the economy and financial markets?
-
Markets1 year ago
Beyond Big Names: The Case for Small- and Mid-Cap Stocks
Small- and mid-cap stocks have historically outperformed large caps. What are the opportunities and risks to consider?
-
Markets1 year ago
Visualizing the Record $6 Trillion in Cash on the Sidelines
Assets in money market funds are at all-time highs. But as investors stockpile cash, are they missing out on today’s stock market rally?
-
Markets2 years ago
What Drove Market Volatility in 2023?
Market volatility is often considered a gauge for investor fear. How did investors react as the economic climate evolved in 2023?
-
Markets2 years ago
3 Reasons Why AI Enthusiasm Differs from the Dot-Com Bubble
Valuations are much lower than they were during the dot-com bubble, but what else sets the current AI enthusiasm apart?
-
Investor Education2 years ago
Paying Less Tax: The Tax-Loss Harvesting Advantage
Learn how tax-loss harvesting works by using capital losses to offset capital gains, potentially reducing your tax bill.
-
Markets2 years ago
Decoding the Economics of a Soft Landing
Will the Federal Reserve achieve a soft landing? Here are key factors that play an important role in the direction of the U.S. economy.
-
Markets2 years ago
3 Reasons to Explore International Stocks Now
International stocks are trading at 20-year lows relative to U.S. stocks, which could present attractive buying opportunities for investors.
-
Markets2 years ago
Fact or Fiction? Test Your Knowledge About Investing During a Recession
From sector performance to market recoveries, test your knowledge about investing during a recession with this interactive quiz.
-
Markets2 years ago
Reimagining the 60/40 Portfolio for Today’s Market
Amid uncertain economic times, a new allocation for the 60/40 portfolio may help investors target higher risk-adjusted returns.
-
Markets2 years ago
The Recession Playbook: Three Strategies for Investors
How can investors prepare for a market downturn? What goes into a recession investment strategy? We look at three sectors to consider.
-
Markets2 years ago
A Visual Guide to Bond Market Dynamics
What factors impact the bond market? Here’s how current interest rates, bond returns, and market volatility compare in a historical context.
-
Investor Education2 years ago
5 Tax Tips for Investors
Learn five tax tips that may help maximize the after-tax value of your investments, including which assets may be best for certain accounts.
-
Markets2 years ago
The Top Google Searches Related to Investing in 2022
What was on investors’ minds in 2022? Discover the top Google searches and how the dominant trends played out in portfolios.